Jan 29, 2011 - Salmaan Taseer    9 Comments

MQM’s identity crisis

This is a brief rant but I have to get it off my chest.
What is wrong with MQM? Is the party suffering from a serious identity crisis? If there is one party that is swinging from this end of the pendulum to the other, it has got to be MQM. Correct me if I am wrong, but wasn’t it the party which was most vocal against the Ahmadi killings last year? Was it not the party that (ostensibly) kicked out Amir Liaquat for making anti Ahmadi remarks on TV? Even though their voters are not all secular (come on, how many people living in Gulistan-e-Jauhar  or Lines Area or even Clifton for that matter, would know what secular actually means, this is Pakistan after all) the party was careful about creating an unambiguous secular voice.
Come 2010 and something spooked them. After years of presenting a secular image, they decided to hijack what used to be Jamat-i-Islami and Tehreek-i-Insaaf’s pet project. They took out a rally demanding the release of Qaum ki Beti Dr Aafia Siddiqui. An MQM insider told me that the reason they took on Aafia Siddiqui (albeit half heartedly) was to counter ANP. Some quarters in Karachi believe that ANP has taken money from Uncle Sam to stay quite about drone attacks in KPK and FATA. In exchange, Uncle Sam would fund their “activities” in Karachi, no matter how questionable they are. According to the same insider, MQM has not shifted ideologically by taking on the case of Aafia Siddiqui, nor did it jump into the popular politics bandwagon for the sake of it, the party just wanted to remind Uncle Sam that they too can play a role in further demonizing them if need be. To an observer, it looks like MQM does not want to leave anything for their opponents to get political mileage from. If an issue can be milked to garner public support – no matter how far removed it is from the political ideology of the party – it will be used. Aafia Siddiqui is one such case.  
Come 2011 and MQM is seriously losing the plot. Yesterday, an MQM Senator refused to offer fateha prayers for slain governor of Punjab, Salmaan Taseer. Senior MQM leader Haider Abbas Rizvi said that it was the senator’s personal position and had nothing to do with party’s stance on the tragic death of Gover Taseer but he should know that it is sending a different signal to people. As if that was not enough, Altaf Bhai went ahead and asked for Qaum ki beti Aafia Siddiqui to be repatriated to Pakistan in exchange of diplomatic immunity for Raymond Davis, an American who killed two Pakistani citizens on Pakistani soil.
From bonfide secular credentials to using Aafia Siddiqui for popular political rhetoric, the party has taken a 180 degrees turn. If they continue the way they are going, it will be difficult to point out an MQM from Jamat-i-Islamis and Tehreek-i-Insaafs of the world. If MQM is resorting to using Aafia Siddiqui, it means things are as gloomy as they can be for secular politics in Pakistan.
Clip to Evernote


  • Tazeen: That was not MQM’s policy. It was a personal action of Senator Pirzada. Haider Abbas has clarified it immediately, and so has the party.

  • There are certain sectarian outfits who don’t belief in “FATEHA KHAWANI” . MQM ranks has all sunni, shia, braveli, deoband, hindu, christian outfit. To ask a deoband to offer fateha doesn’t sound good.

    Oh did you intentionally forgot to mention that MQM attended the funeral of Salman Taseer ?? Which is more important Fateha or Funeral proceeding, oh yes Zardari missed Salman Taseer funeral but attended Hoolbroke, what will you name that kind of crisis ?

  • Insiders say that Uncle Sam is paying ANP…wow….but how deep inside? Can be specific Miss Tazeen?

  • I can see your words trembling… terror is the name of MQM…



  • what is wrong with having an opionion which does not suit you.

    its good,we have democracy in Pakistan,loving it 🙂

  • why do you hate dr Aafia so much ?

  • so the only identity crisis with MQM is because it asked for release of Dr Aafia
    can’t you see the other identity crisis of MQM where it claims to be a political party but also is a heavily armed militant organization involved in target killings ?
    the killings which are taking lives of dozens people every month in YOUR CITY .. you don’t have guts to say a word about them but found time to rant about MQM because of ST & Dr Aafia

    hypocrisy at BEST!

  • Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz…………..
    Wake me up when you have something less cynical to blog.

Got anything to say? Go ahead and leave a comment!

Protected by WP Anti Spam